The UK fiscal environment for international business following Brexit
International tax
The UK fiscal environment for international business following Brexit
Tue 22 Dec 2020
Following the UK’s spending review statement of 25 November, there is now greater clarity on how the UK economy will be taken forward into 2021 following the Covid-19 pandemic and exit from Brexit transition.
Despite incurring record UK government borrowing this year of around £395bn, the significant further borrowing to fund investment during the recovery and in UK infrastructure previously forecast has broadly been retained. While there may be some fiscal policy decisions made to deal with disparities and complications with the current tax system, a radical overhaul of the tax system at this stage looks unlikely and a low interest rate environment may also assist.
We examine below how the UK tax environment is responding to Covid-19 and Brexit demands, and potential impacts on the attractiveness of the UK as an international business location.
Recently proposed changes announced through consultation responses, draft Finance Bill 2020/21 legislation and other initiatives, illustrate how the government is listening to representations made by businesses. In summary, the UK should continue to be a very attractive jurisdiction for international business even after 1 January 2021.
Hybrid and other mismatches – why is this good for the UK?
The UK was the first jurisdiction to implement Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) action 2 rules to deal with hybrid and other mismatches, introducing them from 1 January 2017. Despite subsequent modifications to the rules, they can operate unfairly in several instances, particularly where US ‘check the box’ entities are involved. Changes proposed to the Finance Bill 2020/21, however, could remove many of these difficulties by widening the definition of ‘dual inclusion income’ against which excessive deductions can be offset before restrictions on tax deductions apply.
While this does not solve all the difficulties, it results in a significant widening of the definition of dual inclusion income, so should reduce unfair restrictions on tax deductions of hybrid arrangements.
There are a number of other improvements to the regime, some of which will be retrospective, others talking effect from the date of Royal Assent of Finance Bill 2020/21.
VAT on financial services
Currently when UK financial services businesses sell specified VAT exempt financial services within the EU, there is no right of recovery of input VAT on the associated costs. However, if the sale is made to a non-EU jurisdiction there is a right of recovery for input tax on costs associated with that sale. From 1 January 2021, however, the UK Government will extend the right of recovery of input VAT on costs of making specified financial service sales to the EU. This will be helpful for UK-based financial services businesses and is estimated to cost the UK Exchequer around £1bn annually. Of course, financial services businesses will need to prepare (if they have not already) for a potential hard Brexit, and more detail on this can be found in our summary of a recent FCA Brexit webinar.
Notifications on uncertain tax positions
Several major economies, such as Australia and the US have tax rules requiring larger businesses to notify the revenue authority of uncertain tax positions taken. The UK is considering following suite to help reduce the ‘tax gap’. There had been concern that the definition of ‘uncertain’ for UK purposes would be based on whether HMRC would enquire into a position, which could be an almost impossible judgement for a UK taxpayer to make. The US definition of uncertain is based on a recognised accounting definition, and the Australian uses a taxpayer assessment of whether a tax position is 50% or less likely to be correct.
The UK Government has confirmed that further time will be taken to refine this proposal, potentially leading to a more workable proposal from April 2022.
Double tax agreements
Much has been said regarding the withdrawal of access to EU Directives for UK businesses at the end of the transition period. EU Directives such as the parent/subsidiary and interest and royalties directives can, at present, eliminate withholding taxes on payments between group companies where one is within the UK and one within a different EU jurisdiction.
In its double tax treaty programme, the UK Government has committed to work towards replicating the benefits of those Directives in treaties with individual European jurisdictions.
Notwithstanding this, the UK has an extensive network of double tax agreements which, in many cases, can result in more favourable treatment for related party transactions with a non-EU jurisdiction than most other EU jurisdictions.
Tariffs and customs disruption
Businesses that move goods between the UK and the EU will need to get used to accounting for duty on the movement of goods at the point of crossing the border. If not already considered, this change will force businesses to re-examine their supply chains, logistics management and pricing policies.
There will be winners and losers, but international business will adapt and continue. As a minimum, businesses should be checking whether they have an appropriate EORI, jurisdiction VAT registrations and any fiscal representation required, are geared up to account for and declare goods movements and duties, and have appropriate procedures to manage exchange rate fluctuations. In the UK there is some government assistance for dealing with the change in the form of grants as well as initiatives for establishing freeports.
Infrastructure and equipment spending
Having removed tax allowances for expenditure on industrial buildings from April 2011 (previously around 4% per year), the UK has reintroduced a form of tax allowances for expenditure on structures – the structures and buildings allowance, now at 3% per year.
The recent UK spending review also announced an extension to the 100% tax allowance for expenditure on qualifying plant & machinery of up to £1m annually until 31 December 2021, after which it falls back to £200k. While this allowance will be proportionately more significant for smaller businesses, it still represents an incentive to invest in improved equipment for those seeking to take advantage of the coming UK capital investment opportunities.
Digital services tax
The UK’s digital services tax came into force from 1 April 2020, and there are a number of other measures aimed at taxing profits of multinationals using intangible assets to make sales into the UK market but without a UK presence. These include the ‘offshore receipts in respect of intangible property’ legislation, and a programme to closely examine the transfer pricing strategies and any profit diversion activities of larger businesses.
Taxes such as these will inevitably end up being borne by the consumer, so whether they do much to redistribute tax revenues from multinational businesses to market jurisdictions is open to question. A more recent trend is the unwinding of certain cross border digital corporate structures to recognise a greater proportion of revenue and profit in the jurisdiction of the customer. This may be being driven by the consequences of actions arising from the original 15 BEPS 1.0 reports, potentially making the threat of global apportionment of profit less of a problem. If this trend continues, perhaps the OECD’s pillar 1 proposals for global apportionment may not be required?
Having incurred significant borrowing to support the economy, the UK government, along with other jurisdictions, will be looking to optimise their collection of taxes from larger and multinational businesses. These are tax compliance issues businesses cannot afford to ignore, that are unlikely to become less complex if and when the OECD reforms concerning taxation of the digital economy are adopted.
Ensuring good tax governance practices and preparing for potential international tax disputes is something that should be high on the agenda for international business.
Want to get notified when new blog posts are published?
Subscribe 
New agreement to avoid double taxation between Chile and the United States
This article discusses the effects generated by the agreement which avoids double taxation between Chile and the United States. After many years, this agreement came into force on December 19, 2023, when President Joe Biden signed it. The treaty applies from 1 February 2024 in respect of withholding taxes and applies for all other taxes […]
Chile rejects tax reform bill
In July of 2022, Chile announced a new tax reform seeking to improve tax justice, address tax evasion and encourage economic growth to finance other structural reforms that expand social rights and promote productive and regional development. President Gabriel Boric defended it by saying that redistribution of wealth is key to address the ailments manifested […]
Use of artificial intelligence for tax audits in Mexico
The Tax Administration Service (SAT) is an administrative authority in Mexico empowered to conduct audits of taxpayers with respect to their tax obligations. The primary objective of the SAT is to facilitate and encourage payment of the required taxes and to regulate the imposition of infractions and penalties derived from non-compliance. In the late 1990s, […]
US trust income: opinion of the French administrative Supreme Court clarifies French tax treatment
The French administrative Supreme Court rendered an opinion on 18 April 2023 regarding the French tax treatment of trust income in the French-US context. While this opinion clarifies an area of uncertainty, it certainly raises issues of double taxation which will not improve France’s tax attractiveness when dealing with the US trusts. France does not […]
The French IP Box, an innovative scheme for software creators
The “new” regime of Article 238 of the French Tax Code (FTC) applies to patents in the strict sense, to other industrial property titles such as utility certificates and supplementary protection certificates attached to a patent, but also to software. As such, the regime of article 238 of the CGI applies to software protected by […]
UK Spring Budget 2023: Focus on long-term growth
Everything everywhere The UK Chancellor delivered the 2023 Spring Budget on March 15. Focused on Enterprise, Employment, Education and Everywhere, the measures aim to encourage investment in the UK, increase labor market activity and foster innovation and creativity in the UK. The anti-recessionary measures are expected to have a positive effect across most industries for […]
Tax treatment of US companies in Germany
Background The legal qualification and taxation of US companies in Germany, such as Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) or Subchapter Corporations (S-Corps), can be challenging. One example showing the differences in qualification and taxation can be seen in the different criteria applied for the qualification as a corporation versus a partnership for tax purposes. The ATAD […]
Canada introduces excessive interest and financing expenses limitation rules
Following recommendations of the Base Erosion Profit Shifting (BEPS) report by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Canada is introducing excessive interest and financing expenses limitation (EIFEL) rules. In general terms, EIFEL rules limit the amount of net interest and financing expenses that may be deducted in computing a taxpayer’s income to no […]
Chile looks to overhaul tax credit system
Chile introduced a new tax reform bill on 7th July 2022. The “tax reform towards a fiscal pact for social development and justice” was presented by the Chilean President and is currently progressing through the National Congress. In line with Chile’s ongoing plans to restructure the current system, the bill is aiming for a 4.1% […]
United States responds to Hungary’s global minimum tax veto
On 8 July 2022, the US Treasury Department announced that it would unilaterally terminate its 1979 bilateral treaty with Hungary. The decision follows Hungary’s veto of an EU directive implementing a global minimum tax.
International tax outlook from the UK
International business everywhere will have been affected by the devastating events in Ukraine, with a knock-on impact on energy, supply chains, consequent inflation and the impact of sanctions. This comes with significant developments in the international tax landscape, which also requires attention. This article discusses the tax landscape from a UK perspective, considering domestic and […]
Proposed new EU “UNSHELL” Directive will impose penalties on entities
On 22 December 2021, the European Commission published a proposal for a Directive to prevent the misuse of shell entities for tax purposes (described as “Unshell Directive” or also referred to as ATAD III). The draft Directive aims at identifying and penalising entities that do not maintain sufficient substance within the EU. Additional reporting requirements […]
MNEs subject to 15% minimum tax rate from 2023: main OECD provisions and EU implementation proposals now available
The OECD two-pillar approach In October 2021, the OECD’s 137 Inclusive Framework members agreed to adopt a two-pillar approach to address the tax challenges of the digital economy. Pillar I provides for new profit allocation and nexus rules for MNEs with a turnover greater than EUR 20 billion and profit before tax margins of 10% […]
Is the new two-pillar solution to address tax challenges suitable for African countries?
This new solution is expected to reallocate more than $100bn of profit annually to market jurisdictions. However, this raises the question, to what extent emerging economies, and more specifically, African countries, will be entitled to levy taxes on profits generated by multinational enterprises from their markets? This source and others are sorely needed by these […]
Tax issues arising from corporate amalgamations in Hong Kong
In June 2021 Hong Kong finalised legislation codifying the Inland Revenue Department’s tax assessment practice relating to corporate amalgamations. For qualifying companies, it is possible to elect (within one month of the amalgamation) for special tax treatment for pre-amalgamation losses, succession to business assets, amongst other areas. While the new legislation provides greater certainty on […]
Agreement on OECD pillar 1 and 2 proposals (as refined by the US initiative)
As of 13 July, 132 of 139 jurisdictions (including Bermuda, Cayman Islands, BVI, Switzerland, and the Bahamas) agreed to the OECD Pillar 1 and 2 proposals as refined by the US initiative. The seven that did not were: Ireland, Estonia, Hungary, Barbados, Kenya, Nigeria, Sri Lanka. The OECD press release can be found here and […]
Recent developments in the concept of a permanent establishment in Chile
International taxation is based on residence as the point of connection of a subject with a given territory. However, today’s world is characterized by open economies competing to attract many companies and governed by technology. Apart from the tax connection point represented by the tax domicile in a given country, another element relevant when taxing […]
G7 Global tax agreement
The finance ministers of the G7 have issued a news brief indicating their agreement on global tax reform that “….will mean the largest multinational tech giants will pay their fair share of tax in the countries in which they operate….”. This consists of two parts: global firms with at least a 10% profit margin would […]
Brexit impact on in/outbound payments
When the UK finally left the EU ended on 31 December 2020, the application of provisions that have been beneficial to cross-border payments within the EU ceased, or will cease to apply. The elimination of withholding taxes, formerly part of these provisions, means companies with cross-border dividend, interest and royalty payment flows to or from […]
New German tax developments regarding intellectual property (IP)
Decree of the Federal Ministry of Finance dated 11 February 2021 – Remuneration of the temporary transfer and the disposal of rights which are entered in a German public register. Further information on German tax developments relating to intellectual property (IP) registered in Germany has been released by the German Authorities. This helps to clarify how the German taxing right can apply to non-German users or vendors of this IP. This […]
Changes to interest deduction limitation rules
The EU Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD), contains five legally binding anti-abuse measures, which all EU member states are required to apply against common forms of aggressive tax planning. The Directive includes an exit tax, a general anti-abuse rule, controlled foreign company rules, measures to tackle hybrid mismatch arrangements, in addition to an interest limitation rule. We […]
OECD recommendations on comparability analysis during Covid-19 (Part 2)
Covid-19 has brought unprecedented social and economic challenges that will durably impact the world economy. Specifically, the pandemic has surrounded the Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) with many issues to be managed such as: insufficient cash flows, unpredictable profitability, unreliable third-party data (which is at the heart of arm’s length principle), non-operative supply chains, import/export limitations, possible […]
OECD recommendations on comparability analysis during Covid-19 (Part 1)
Covid-19 has brought unprecedented social and economic challenges that will durably impact the world economy. Specifically, the pandemic has surrounded the Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) with many issues to be managed such as: insufficient cash flows, unpredictable profitability, unreliable third-party data (which is at the heart of arm’s length principle), non-operative supply chains, import/export limitations, possible […]
Making sense of tax systems in a digitalised world
How do we develop a global tax system that takes into account business innovation and the digitalised economy, yet is fair to all stakeholders? It’s a debate world governments continue to grapple with as they consider radical reforms to adapt century-old tax rules to the 21st-century digital economy. It’s also a question we put to […]
TRACE made it to the EU Commission’s agenda. Yet another burden approaching? Or an opportunity?
On 24 September 2020, the European Commission published Communication COM (2020) 590 (final) regarding the action plan in respect to the Capital Markets Union. Action 10 of this plan envisages a EU legislative initiative by Q4 2022 to introduce a common, standardised, EU-wide system for withholding tax relief at source, based on the OECD Treaty Relief and Compliance Enhancement (“TRACE”) Implementation Package. What is this […]
Another ‘Google’ tax hits this week – this time in Spain
Following the path of other developed countries (e.g., France, United Kingdom, Italy), Spain enacted last October a brand new “tax on certain digital services” that will come into effect on 16 January 2021. Background of a tax (not so new) The origin of this tax can be found in Action 1 of the BEPS report […]
Important tax developments for digital economy
Over the past few years, the digital economy has become a hot topic around the world. The international community has made substantial progress towards reaching a consensus-based and long-term solution to prevent tax challenges arising from the digitalisation of the economy. Seeking to keep working towards an agreement by mid-2021, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation […]
OECD guidance about the transfer pricing implications of the Covid-19 pandemic
The OECD released its guidance on the transfer pricing implications of the Covid-19 pandemic on 18 December 2020. This guidance was eagerly awaited by many MNEs whose statutory accounts will be closed by the end of the year, and which need to adjust their 2020 transfer pricing policies to reflect the financial impact of the […]
French landmark decision fighting against “commissionaire” arrangements in the digital economy
After the French government enacted a 3% digital services tax on gross income, it is now the French Administrative Supreme Court which rendered a landmark decision for international groups providing digital services in France by strongly extending the definition of permanent establishment in the presence of commissionaires. This new case law remains also relevant for […]
Permanent establishment through a management company
BEPS 2.0 continues to call into question what indeed is a permanent establishment (PE). We all know that ‘bricks and mortar’ is almost ‘a ghost of Christmas past’ and states are now focused more on activities that have the potential to create nexus or PE status. This is certainly the underpinning of the sweeping world […]
Tax holiday checklists: make your list and check it twice, especially for withholding tax changes
Generally speaking, year-end is that time of year when we clean up all open items in the current year and head into the new year with a fresh outlook and perspective. This also applies to tax. You cannot be blind to the overwhelming number of tax checklists published to help individuals, in particular, get their tax affairs […]
The new year brings new social security challenges post- Brexit
What is the issue? With Brexit talks still ongoing, employers should be planning for the impact of a hard Brexit on social security coverage and benefit provision for their employees who travel between the UK and EU (including EEA & EFTA countries and Switzerland) for work. HMRC’s October employer bulletin provided a welcome update on […]
Is patience growing thin for a unified approach to digital taxation?
The global economy is experiencing digital transformation at a blistering pace with the rise of e-commerce. The digital economy permeates all aspects of life including how we eat, sleep, breathe, and communicate. It has immense impact on the world’s economic landscape touching all industries and sectors from aviation to wholesale trade. The digital economy is […]
ICAP 2.0 – A solution to aggressive tax audits for MNEs during Covid-19
Governments damaged by the Covid-19 pandemic are likely to be taking a more aggressive approach in tax field audits on multinational enterprises (MNEs), at least until after their respective economy is on its way to recovering from the impacts of the pandemic. The OECD launched a pilot of the International Compliance Assurance Programme (ICAP) on […]
The future of joint tax audits beyond Covid-19
The current restrictions imposed by multiple countries to combat the Covid-19 pandemic have limited the possibilities for conducting external tax audits. However, the current pandemic and its consequences for the world economy highlight again that the number of internationally active companies is increasing. This has a significant impact on the future of tax audits. Coordinated […]