Green bonds: is an oasis within reach?
Energy Transactions
Green bonds: is an oasis within reach?
Mon 02 Mar 2020
The global green bond market has expanded rapidly in recent years, growing by 75% between 2016 and 2018 and recording an issue volume of 175 billion dollars in 2018. One of the new features of this market is the issuing of securities by a variety of non-public players, including non-financial firms. We also expect the market will continue to consist primarily of issues from European companies – corresponding to the need for additional investments in Europe to the tune of €180 billion annually, in order to achieve the targets set by the EU in the Paris Agreement by 2030.
Green bonds: a fast-growing market but lacks structure
France holds the record for the largest green bond issue ever, for an amount of 7 billion euros, which reflects the government’s proactive approach to the Paris Agreement objectives. Launched in January 2017, the green OAT (Obligation Assimilable au Trésor) offered a 1.75% return with a duration of 22 years. The OAT funds the budget of the French central government and the “Invest for the Future” programme, which aims to fight climate change, protect biodiversity and tackle pollution.
According to the International Capital Market Association (ICMA), “green” bonds are any type of bond instrument where the proceeds will be exclusively applied to finance or re-finance, in part or in full, an eligible green project. They present many advantages, above all to investors. Firstly, a diversification of risk and a choice between several types, of which the following are the best known:
- Green Revenue Bonds, non-recourse bonds with limited exposure to the issuer’s revenue flows;
- Green Project Bonds, with direct exposure to the project;
- Green Securitised Bonds, collateralised by specific projects or leasing – for example, of photovoltaic installations.
Strong market demand for green bonds is leading players to better formalise the definition of eligibility criteria, and to introduce more transparency in a bid to improve the confidence of investors. In the case of the French OAT, the government’s identification of dedicated allocations by category also contributes to greater investor visibility.
For issuers, green bonds go hand in hand with the acceleration of investment, since they are a way to rapidly raise money on a massive scale in the markets. This investment also meets a dual need. Firstly, the general pressure on the market from a wide range of players – institutions, civil society, shareholders – to invest in green projects; secondly, the desire to fulfil their environmental, social and governance commitments (ESG). In France, green bonds provide an excellent means for regional bodies, for example (not least small-scale bodies that can pool the debt they issue), to communicate their environmental strategies and to diversify and better target investors interested in green projects.
Nonetheless, the technical, economic and regulatory limitations mean green bonds still need to be carefully considered before investment is made.
For issuers, producing reports is still a common obstacle. Of the 25 issuers listed today in France, only 16 have produced an available report, and six others have either produced a report which is hard to access, or have not published one at all. The small bodies that could benefit from this increased investment are confronted, in particular, with lengthy procedures and the arduous mobilisation of resources and staff.
Green bonds are also in competition with “social bonds” or “sustainable bonds”, which focus on social and environmental challenges (with 35% growth in 2018, reaching €30 billion) and which therefore attract ESG investors. This overlap makes a clear definition of “green” bonds aa complex matter.
From a regulatory standpoint, there is currently no binding legal framework for the choice of projects, the production of reports and the issuing of green securities. The French OAT, for example, is subject to the Green Bond Principles, a symbolic guide to good practices published by the ICMA. Meanwhile, the framework guidelines are multiplying regionally and internationally: the European Union intends to create a non-binding Green Bond Standard, as does the International Organization for Standardization. Other players, such as the rating agency Moody’s also offer to assess, verify and certify “green” bonds, reflecting the regulatory void. But, as it stands, there is no current harmonisation of the tools and rules for assessing and choosing green projects.
Finally, despite the great attraction of green bonds as a means of financing the green transition, many questions remain: how to avoid the spin-off effects, including the question of greenwashing, which is currently dominating debate on the transparency of green investments. And is the issuing of green bonds really appropriate for the mainly local demand in both France and Europe, when these issues are mainly devoted to major projects and infrastructure?
Article co-authored by Edouard Lecoeur, Partner, Public, Infrastructure and Real Estate Advisory and Adrien Dubié, Senior Manager, Infrastructure and Energy.
Energy price volatility: a major risk to be addressed
The cost of natural gas in Europe reached €345 per megawatt-hour (MWh) in August 2022, compared to €29 in June 2021. Similarly, the cost of electricity soared to 1,000 €/MWh versus €85 less than a year before. It would be an understatement to say that the recent energy price volatility generated a significant challenge for […]
Q3 2023 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q3 2023 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Q2 2023 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q2 2023 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Q1 2023 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q1 2023 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Webinar | Hydrogen projects – developing your investment case
Watch our joint webinar with CMS to learn more about hydrogen. We discuss hydrogen project modelling, the rapidly evolving regulatory aspects supporting the hydrogen economy, and building an effective investment case critical to business decisions. The future of energy production around the globe is transforming. Hydrogen shows growing potential in the transition to a low-carbon […]
Q4 2022 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q4 2022 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Locational pricing – how UK energy market reform could impact asset valuations
Locational marginal pricing, if introduced, would represent the biggest change to the UK’s electricity market for decades, and its impact on asset valuations could be profound. In May 2022, National Grid ESO published its Net Zero Market Report, which explored the current market design for electricity across Britain. The report concluded that: “Britain’s electricity market […]
Q3 2022 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q3 2022 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP): managing project handbacks
Public-Private Partnerships (PPP), also known as Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) in the UK, have become a solution to a gap in public investment derived from natural budgetary constraints worldwide. This model is based upon joint working and risk sharing and brings together private sector solutions, technologies and investments and public sector oversight. Long-term PPP contracts […]
Q1 2022 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q1 2022 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Q4 2021 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q4 2021 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Q3 2021 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Welcome to the Q3 2021 edition of our quarterly valuation update, which provides a snapshot of some of the main publicly available valuation trends across the energy and infrastructure sector, covering both debt and equity metrics. This quarter we continue to look at trends in debt and equity metrics relying primarily on publicly available information. […]
Restructuring Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) – part 2: challenges and key success factors
In recent years, the market has seen an increasing number of high-profile defaults of Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) – and the risk remains that these continue going forward. After examining major risk factors causing distress in part one of this two-part series, we focus in this article on common issues and […]
Restructuring Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) – part 1: causes of distress
Private Finance Initiatives (PFI) and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) have come under increased scrutiny in recent years after a rising number of defaults. In part one of this two-part series, we examine five major risk factors causing distress, while in part two, we reveal common issues and key success factors when it comes to restructuring PFI […]
Q2 2021 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
This quarter we continue to explore trends in debt and equity metrics and have included a spotlight on digital infrastructure funds, looking at some emerging valuation trends from the two digital infrastructure funds that have recently been listed on the London Stock Exchange.
Q1 2021 quarterly valuation update for the energy and infrastructure sector
Infrastructure is an increasingly mature asset class, with a growing number of listed and unlisted funds established specifically to invest in and manage real assets across the energy and infrastructure sectors. To provide a fresh perspective on valuation metrics, Mazars has launched the ‘quarterly valuation update’ for the global energy and infrastructure sectors, covering both […]
Covid-19: emerging trends on the availability and cost of infra debt
In a previous article, I wrote about the early impact of Covid-19 on equity valuations across the energy and infrastructure space, noting changing cashflow expectations in some sectors, but not necessarily all, and no general trend of higher discount rates. I will provide an update of valuation trends in a future piece, but in this […]
Early market reactions to Covid-19 in the energy and infrastructure deal universe
It has been some few weeks. I am writing this from home, connected to team members and clients through technology but otherwise working in isolation, and this experience will be familiar to nearly all of our clients around the world. As well as its direct impact on people who have contracted the disease, Covid-19 has […]
How to avoid bad renewable energy deals # 1: introduction
The renewable energy sector has experienced its fair share of bad deals. Some sub-sectors and geographies have seen particular systemic issues that go beyond individual projects but the sector has actually been good at learning lessons from failures – especially legal and technical.
Renewable energy assets – how the market is pricing in longer asset lives
Current state of valuations in the renewable energy markets A short thought to kick off with, based on experience working with a global client base of renewable energy developers, financiers, investors and asset managers. Across markets, valuations of renewable energy assets are continuing to rise, and we are seeing evidence of this everywhere – from […]
Energy: Opportunities for storage asset development (APAC)
Storage is the next frontier in the global transition to renewable energy. Some markets are moving at a more rapid pace than others, and in our recent breakfast briefings on the topic ‘valuation of storage assets’, presented in collaboration with Norton Rose Fulbright, we discussed the experiences from the United Kingdom, Australia and the United […]
Subsidy-free renewables: have we reached the tipping point?
Mazars and Eversheds Sutherland jointly hosted a panel event attended by nearly 100 industry participants focusing on the viability of subsidy-free renewables in the UK. Welcoming experts from across the sector, our panel discussed the major topics in the industry, and addressed questions from the audience. The main outcomes of the discussion were that: The […]
Addressing Crypto-Currency’s Energy Problem
The value of Bitcoin as a worldwide payment system and ongoing investment in the currency, has been a rollercoaster ride from December 2017, when prices surged above $19,000 per Bitcoin, to June 2018, when each coin fell to approximately $7,000. Bitcoin is produced by computers via blockchain technology, which is a record of transactions maintained […]