Supreme Court considers IHT issues of gratuitous benefit and transfer of value for pension fund transfers omission to take benefits
Supreme Court considers IHT issues of gratuitous benefit and transfer of value for pension fund transfers omission to take benefits
Mon 09 Nov 2020
The Supreme Court has partially overturned the Court of Appeal in the case of Parry and others (see the press release and decision). While the case concerned legislation and practice with respect to pension funds now superseded for dispositions made on or after 6 April 2011 (as a result of new IHTA 1984 s12(2A)), there may be useful principles to take from the case concerning when gratuitous intent exists and when there is a transfer of value.
Contrary to the Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court held that the transfer of funds from a deferred annuity contract to a personal pension plan, undertaken shortly before Mrs Staveley’s death in December 2006, was not a transfer intended to confer gratuitous benefit. Therefore it did not amount to a transfer of value as a result of IHTA 1984 s10. The Supreme Court considered the intended beneficiaries were the same before and after the transfer.
In agreement with the Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court held that the omission to take benefits would result in someone’s estate increasing and therefore (according to the legislation in force at the time), there was a transfer of value as a result of IHTA 1984 s3(3).
In broad summary the purpose of the transfer between pension funds by Mrs Staveley was to ensure her ex-husband could not benefit, should surplus funds from the deferred annuity contract be returned to the company which set it up for her.
HMRC guidance at IHTM17037 does indicate that the transfer of value issue concerning the failure to take benefits, no longer applies for deaths occurring on or after 6 April 2011 – for a member of a registered pension scheme (amongst others).
For a further discussion of the tax issues around pension transfers and death benefit, particularly where for those reaching the age of 75, please get in touch with a member of the Mazars personal tax or financial planning teams.
Tooth nails the meaning of ‘Deliberate’ – and eradicates ‘Staleness’
The long-running saga of Raymond Tooth versus HMRC reached its conclusion in the Supreme Court recently when the Court dismissed the assessment that HMRC had made upon him. The case has been keenly followed by tax professionals through the First Tier and Upper Tribunals and the Court of Appeal because it focused on two important […]
EU moves towards eliminating cross-border IHT problems
The Confederation Fiscale Europeenne (CFE) (a pan European body representing tax professionals) has published examples of specific examples of cross-border IHT problems encountered by its members.
High-value home owners’ £1million IHT threshold delayed till 2020
From 6 April 2017 a new additional nil-rate band (we’ll call it the ANRB) will be available on residential property left to children and remoter descendants but the change will not come fully into effect until 6 April 2020. Like the standard NRB, the ANRB will be transferable to a spouse or civil partner with […]
New domicile rules from 2017
On 6 April 2017 a simplification will be made that, for once, doesn’t flout the Trades Descriptions Act. The new deemed domicile rule will apply for all personal and trust taxation purposes unless something goes seriously wrong in the consultation process. New deemed domicile rule The Budget speech announced that non-domiciled individuals who have been […]
Restrictions to Tax Planning for Non-Doms – Fairer but there may still be opportunities for Non-Doms to save UK Tax
The Chancellor claimed that the current rules for the taxation of non-domiciled individuals had ‘an important place’ and would not be dumped outright before announcing significant proposals to the current regime to make the UK tax system fairer. It’s difficult to argue that the proposals will not make the system fairer but it seems doubtful […]
National Employee Ownership Day – 2015 is better than ever!
3rd July 2015 is National Employee Ownership Day in the UK. The purpose of EO Day is to highlight the benefits of employee ownership to business, whether this is direct ownership, using share plans, or indirect ownership using an employee ownership trust and following the well known John Lewis model; or a hybrid approach using a […]
Push the POAT out? Asset revaluation brings more property over the threshold
The pre-owned assets tax (POAT) was ten years old on 6 April 2015 but no party was held because nobody would have attended. Introduced as a countermeasure against inheritance tax avoidance schemes, POAT applies to anyone who disposed of an asset after 17 March 1986 who subsequently occupies or enjoys the use of that property […]
Charity begins abroad: offshore charities and UK tax reliefs
The case of Routier and Venables v HMRC concerned a bequest to charity under the will of C and possible relief from inheritance tax (IHT) under IHTA 1984 s 23.
Pilot trusts ejected: ten-year anniversary and exit charges not simplified enough
The proposals to simplify trust exit and ten-year anniversary (TYA) charges, due to come into effect on 6 April 2015 have been modified in the consultation document Inheritance tax: A fairer way of calculating trust charges issued by HMRC on 6 June 2014. These are the new restrictions on the nil-rate band available to trusts […]
High court rules assets re-entering offshore trust not excluded property in Barclays Wealth Jersey v HMRC
The case of Barclays Wealth Trustees (Jersey) limited v HMRC ([2015] EWHC 2878 (Ch)) has ruled that property that was originally IHT ‘excluded property’ but ceased to be so when it was transferred to another settlement, in which it was no longer excluded property, did not revert to being excluded property when the second settlement […]
New intestacy and trust rules from October 2014
The new Inheritance and Trustees’ Powers Act 2014 (ITPA 2014), due to come into force on 1 October 2014 includes changes affecting how: intestate estates are distributed; and trustees can distribute income and capital to beneficiaries These changes apply to individuals domiciled in England and Wales at date of death. The changes are of no […]
Pilot trusts and the IHT “simplification”: the wait continues
The major part of the reform of IHT on trusts concerns the ten year charge (formally the “principal charge”) on trusts. However, proposals made in the 2013 Budget would have meant that no matter how many trusts a settlor might set up in lifetime, all those trusts could only share one nil-rate band (NRB). One […]
IHT relief for liabilities: non-sterling bank account loophole closed
With effect from Royal Assent to FB 2014 a refinement to the FA 2013 provisions restricting relief for liabilities will close a loophole available to non-UK resident non-UK domiciliaries. The new s 162A IHTA 1984, introduced by FA 2013, restricts the ability to claim a deduction for certain loans against an individual’s estate for IHT […]
Simplification of IHT charges on trusts
Individuals who have established trusts need to be aware of forthcoming changes to their tax treatment, due in April 2015. Those looking to use trusts as part of a wealth management/succession plan will need to consider whether the use of a trust is still worthwhile. The first phase of the changes aimed at simplifying the […]
Does ‘simplification’ really mean trusts pay more tax?
The first phase of the changes aimed to simplify the way in which inheritance tax (‘IHT’) is charged on trusts will be introduced from April. Their stated intention is to be tax neutral but they look likely to increase trusts’ tax burdens. The HMRC consultation process has so far demonstrated that the position will be […]
No IHT Business Property Relief for industrial units lettings business
Best (Buller’s executor) v RCC (UKFTT 03217) follows the example set in HMRC v Lockyer, executor of Pawson in refusing BPR on a property letting business. Best differs from Lockyer in facts but not in principle. The differences are that: in Lockyer the property concerned was a single furnished holiday property that was accepted to […]
Availability of IHT Business Property Relief
The professional bodies have issued a technical release on the availability of BPR in two situations. Firstly, where shares in unquoted trading companies are held by partnerships or LLPs. Secondly, where surplus cash is held by businesses and companies, which has been increasingly common in recent economic conditions. BPR treatment of Partnership/ LLP Interest in […]
IHT: nil-rate band residential enhancements
The Summer Finance Bill (SFB) includes the new Inheritance Tax Act 1984 sections 8D to 8M and consequential amendments to other sections introducing the additional nil-rate band for residential property. The new additional nil-rate band is referred to in the bill in various ways but is likely to settle on “residence nil-rate amount” (RNRA). The […]
IHT deemed domicile aligned with new 15/20 rule
The Draft Finance Bill 2016 extends the deemed domicile rules announced for other taxes to IHT, so that for once the rules are consistent across all taxes. The content of the DFB shows minimal change from the announcements made in the Summer Budget. At that time it was not clear whether the new rule […]
HMRC ignores its own behaviour on “Nudge Letters”
It seems that HMRC is immune to the very behavioural techniques which it has so enthusiastically adopted (such as the use of “nudge letters”) to influence taxpayers’ behaviour in complying with the UK tax legislation. In our blog on nudge letters, we highlighted that HMRC were hoping to make recipients of the letters feel uncomfortable […]
De-enveloping properties held in corporate wrappers
We now know that inheritance tax benefits previously associated with the use of corporate structures to hold UK residential property will be removed with effect from 6 April 2017. The new rules treat the interest in the holding entity as subject to UK IHT. Previously it could be exempt in the hands of a non-UK […]
HMRC fail to unseat “DIY-plus” horse livery services’ IHT business property relief
The upper tribunal (UT) has turned down HMRC’s appeal in Vigne against the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) decision that “DIY-Plus” livery services provided to clients who stabled their horses with the late Mrs. Vigne were enough for inheritance tax (IHT) business property relief (BPR) to apply to the business. BPR applies to any business that is not wholly […]
Finance Bill 2018-19 – tax administration points
Included in the draft finance bill legislation issued on 6 July 2018 on those measures affecting tax administration, were provisions relating to extension of offshore time limits for assessing certain taxes, extension of the security deposit regime, and profit fragmentation. HMRC has requested comments on the draft legislation by 31 August 2018. There were also […]
Yet another nail in the coffin for offshore arrangements?
The UK Government has introduced a raft of legislation to address tax evasion and latterly tax avoidance. This has included; The Requirement to Correct legislation which has introduced punitive offshore penalties and extended assessing time limits for Income Tax, Inheritance Tax and Capital Gains Tax to 5 April 2021 and, Enhancing automatic exchanges of information […]
The Advertising Standards Authority stamps on misleading tax claims
In its pursuit of stamping out tax avoidance HMRC complained to the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) about misleading tax claims by the promoter, CDP Tax & Wealth Limited, which trades under the name Fiducia Wealth and Tax (FWT). FWT’s website advertised a tax planning scheme which it said could reduce Stamp Duty Land Tax bills […]
Trust continuity preserves IHT excluded property status in Court of Appeal
Recent changes in the domicile rules affecting an individual’s inheritance tax (IHT) non-domicile status can have serious effects on trusts they have set up. Overseas assets settled on trust when the settlor was non-domiciled are excluded property for IHT purposes which means those assets are not liable for IHT charges when they become or cease […]
Heritage property IHT conditional exemption for buildings of outstanding interest- opening times
One of the less well-known and sometimes overlooked tax exemptions is the conditional exemption (CE) from inheritance tax (IHT) and capital gains tax (CGT) for buildings of outstanding historical or architectural interest. For this exemption to apply you don’t have to put the property into a special vehicle such as a trust: it can still […]
Horse-sense reigns in Vigne- “DIY livery-plus” not denied IHT business relief
The personal representatives of the estate of Maureen W. Vigne (deceased) have successfully appealed against HMRC’s refusal of inheritance tax business property relief (BPR) The case turned on whether MRs Vigne had run a business that required land or was mainly holding the land as an investment and the trading activities carried out on the […]
Changes to UK ‘Non Dom’ tax rules effective by the end of 2017
The UK government announced on 13 July that changes to the tax treatment of individuals who are resident in the UK but are non-UK domiciliaries, and which were put on hold because of the UK General Election, will now go ahead in a second Finance Bill which should become law by the end of 2017. […]
IHT- residence nil-rate band downsizing provisions in draft Finance Bill 2016
The progress of the additional nil-rate band for residences has been rather slow and tortuous: first the basics of Residence nil-rate band (RNRB) were set out in the Summer Budget and Finance (No.2) Act 2015 but at that time nothing was said about downsizing provisions except that there would be some. The Draft Finance Bill […]
Hastings-Bass was the solvent that unstuck a sticky IHT situation
Power Adhesives Ltd. almost came unstuck when, under the guidance of their advisers, the Company adopted an inappropriate arrangement to remove the possible problem of having to repay a director’s loan account on death. The arrangement made, for non-tax reasons, would have created an IHT liability on an amount far greater than the loan itself. […]
Shareholder’s estate spared huge IHT liability by Hastings-Bass
A company almost came unstuck when, under the guidance of their advisers, the Company adopted an inappropriate arrangement to remove the possible problem of having to repay a director’s loan account on death. The arrangement made, for non-tax reasons, would have created an IHT liability on an amount far greater than the loan itself. The […]
Inheritance tax (IHT) planning through equity release
Press coverage of opportunities afforded by falling interest rates has included reference to the possibility of using borrowing to fund lifetime gifts that, as potentially exempt transfers (PETs), completely escape the donor’s IHT estate so long as the donor survives for seven years after making the gift. The rationale of the idea is that an […]
IHT hallmarked for DOTAS
The Government has had second thoughts about the new IHT hallmarks for DOTAS. The result is a new proposal of two, not three hallmarks based on the original proposals. These represent a more realistic understanding of the issues in IHT but they are still attracting criticism due to the breadth of their potential scope which could […]
Supreme Court Settles Eclipse 35 Dispute
The sun has set on litigation that started in 2012 between HMRC and Eclipse Film Partners No 35 LLP (“Eclipse 35”). The Supreme Court comprising of five Lords has refused Eclipse 35 permission to appeal. The permission to appeal was refused in under an hour demonstrating the definitive position of the law as summarised by […]
Supreme Court to Settle the Eclipse 35 Dispute
Following a Court of Appeal ruling in February 2015 which found in favour of HMRC that Eclipse Film Partners No 35 LLP (“Eclipse 35”) did not carry on a trade, the Supreme Court will this week hear the appeal by Eclipse 35 against the Court of Appeal’s decision. This is the latest and, very probably, […]
Bankers’ bonus scheme bashed by Supreme Court
Two schemes designed to enable employees to realise significant cash sums without suffering income tax or PAYE have been ruled ineffective by the Supreme Court (SC), overturning the surprising judgment of the Court of Appeal in the companies’ favour. Redeemable shares were issued by offshore companies created by UBS and DB specifically and solely for […]
Court of Appeal reins back IHT reservation of benefit in Buzzoni
HMRC have lost in the Court of Appeal in Buzzoni v RCC, re the estate of Lia Kamhi deceased, a case they won in the First and Upper Tier Tribunals. ‘Ingram’ carve-out schemes whereby the donor of an asset, usually land, could reduce the IHT value of their estate by retaining a minor interest (e.g. […]